§ 5 — Detach
Do Not Claim Yourselves Pure
It usually starts as a quiet thought.
You have been changing. You have been reading, praying more, giving more. You turned off the phone at night. You let go of things you used to hold onto. And it feels good. You can see where your hours are going, and for the first time in a long time, more of them are going to the right side of the hourglass.
Then one evening you are sitting with your family, or your friends, or your colleagues at lunch. Someone is scrolling through their phone the whole time. Someone is talking about the new car they are going to buy, and the one after that. Someone mentions, almost proudly, that they have not prayed in months.
And a thought arrives, very calmly:
They are so attached.
It does not feel like anger. It feels like clarity. You can see it so clearly in them now. The grip of the world. The loop. The grains of sand all falling the wrong way. You almost feel sorry for them. And somewhere under the pity, if you are honest, there is something warm and pleasant. A feeling of standing a little higher. Of being one of the people who sees.
This chapter is about that warm feeling. Because it is not clarity. It is one of the oldest attachments there is, and it is the one most likely to grow out of a book like this.
A mirror, not a window#
Everything in this book is a lens. The hourglass. The four dimensions. The idea that every feeling and every action is either an attachment or a detachment. These are ways of seeing.
And a lens can be turned in two directions.
Turned toward yourself, it is a mirror. It shows you where your own heart is tied, and it helps you let go. Turned toward other people, it becomes a window you look through at their lives, sorting them. Attached. Very attached. Hopeless. The same words that were meant to free you become a measuring stick for everyone else.
The second way feels like progress. It is not. It is one more thing the heart has taken hold of: an image of itself as the one who is further along. And it may be the most dangerous image of all, because it is made out of good things. Out of prayer, and charity, and letting go. It is an attachment that wears the clothes of detachment.
In the chapter “Detach from Perfection,” we saw a heart that falls, and then believes it has lost its future with Allah. That heart is attached to despair. This chapter is about its twin: a heart that rises a little, and then believes it has secured its future with Allah, and can now see everyone else’s. That heart is attached to certainty. Both have forgotten the same thing. Neither of us knows how our story ends.
An arm’s length#
The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ described how every human being is formed in the womb, stage by stage, and how an angel is sent to write down four things for each of us: our provision, our lifespan, our deeds, and whether we will end in misery or in happiness. And then he said something that should silence every one of us who has ever felt safe:
“A man among you may do the deeds of the people of Paradise until there is only an arm’s length between him and it. Then what was written overtakes him, and he does the deeds of the people of the Fire, and he enters it. And a man may do the deeds of the people of the Fire until there is only an arm’s length between him and it. Then what was written overtakes him, and he does the deeds of the people of Paradise, and he enters it.”
Sahih al-Bukhari 3208, 6594; Sahih Muslim 2643
An arm’s length. After a whole life of walking toward Paradise, the distance left could be shorter than your own arm. And the man walking toward the Fire could be just as close to the turn.
This hadith is not saying that our deeds are meaningless, or that Allah treats anyone unjustly. The Prophet ﷺ explained what it means in another story, and the explanation is the whole point of this chapter.
There was a battle. One man fought for the Muslims more fiercely than anyone else. He chased down every enemy fighter who strayed from the lines. The companions said that no one had done better that day. And the Prophet ﷺ said: if anyone wants to see a man of the people of the Fire, let him look at him.
One of the companions decided to follow the man and watch. The man was wounded. He could not bear the pain, and he rushed his own death, setting the tip of his sword against his chest and leaning on it until it came out through his back. The companion ran back to the Prophet ﷺ, and the Prophet ﷺ said:
“A man may do what appears to the people to be the deeds of the people of Paradise, while he is of the people of the Fire. And a man may do what appears to the people to be the deeds of the people of the Fire, while he is of the people of Paradise. And deeds are judged by their endings.”
Sahih al-Bukhari 6493, 6607; Sahih Muslim 112
What appears to the people. That is what we see. The surface. The prayer we watched him pray, the bottle we saw in her hand, the post, the car, the empty seat in the mosque. We see the deeds. We never see the heart that is doing them, and we never see the ending.
The scholars who explained this hadith said that this is what the “arm’s length” really means: the one who turns at the end was carrying something hidden all along, something no one else could see, sometimes something he could barely see himself. And the one who turns toward Paradise at the end was carrying something hidden too. A sincerity. A regret. A small, private goodness that only Allah knew about.
Which means that when you look at someone and decide what they are, you are deciding with half the information. Less than half. You are reading one page of a book and announcing how it ends.
Nearer than your sandal strap#
There is a short hadith that I keep coming back to, because it cuts both ways at once:
“Paradise is nearer to any of you than the strap of his sandal, and so is the Fire.”
Sahih al-Bukhari 6488
The strap of your sandal is the closest thing to you that you never think about. It is right there, against your foot, with every step.
That is how near Paradise is. And that is how near the Fire is. The Prophet ﷺ explained how small the step can be:
“A servant may speak a word that pleases Allah without giving it a thought, and Allah raises him by degrees because of it. And a servant may speak a word that angers Allah without giving it a thought, and it drops him into the Fire.”
Sahih al-Bukhari 6478
One word, said without thinking. That is the width of a sandal strap.
Now put the hadith of the sandal strap next to the person you are looking down on. Paradise is as close to them as their sandal strap. One sincere word in the night, one turning of the heart that you will never see, and they are there.
And then put it next to yourself. The Fire is as close to you as your own sandal strap. And the word that takes you there could be the very word you were about to say about them.
The woman and the dog#
The Prophet ﷺ told a story that I think was meant to unsettle exactly the kind of person who feels sure about other people.
“A dog was circling a well, about to die of thirst. A prostitute from the Children of Israel saw it. She took off her shoe and drew water for it with it, and gave it to drink. And Allah forgave her because of it.”
Sahih al-Bukhari 3467
Think about who would have passed that woman in the street that day. Think about what they would have thought of her, and what they would have said about her later. Most of us would have been certain. We would have known exactly what she was and where she was going.
And Allah forgave her, for one act of mercy toward a thirsty dog, that no one saw.
The Prophet ﷺ also said:
“Many a person with disheveled hair, covered in dust, turned away from people’s doors, is such that if he swore by Allah, Allah would fulfill it.”
Sahih Muslim 2622
The person turned away from the door. The one nobody wanted at the table. The one we did not look at twice. That person may be so close to Allah that Allah would not let their word fall.
We do not know who is who. That is the lesson, over and over. We do not know.
Who swears on My behalf?#
Now we come to the hardest story in this chapter, because the man in it was not a sinner. He was a worshipper.
The Prophet ﷺ told of two men among the Children of Israel. One of them kept falling into sin. The other worked hard in worship. The worshipper kept seeing his friend in sin, and kept telling him: stop. One day he found him in sin again, and said again: stop. And the man said:
“Leave me with my Lord. Were you sent as a watchman over me?”
And the worshipper said: “By Allah, Allah will not forgive you. Allah will not admit you into Paradise.”
Then both of them died, and they stood before the Lord of the worlds. And Allah said to the worshipper:
“Did you have knowledge of Me? Or did you have power over what is in My hand?”
And He said to the sinner: “Go, and enter Paradise by My mercy.” And of the worshipper, He said: “Take him to the Fire.”
Abu Hurairah, who narrated it, said: “By the One in whose hand is my soul, he spoke a word that destroyed his world and his Hereafter.”
Sunan Abi Dawud 4901 (graded authentic by al-Albani). A shorter version is in Sahih Muslim 2621: “Who is this who swears on My behalf that I will not forgive so-and-so? I have forgiven him, and I have made your deeds worthless.”
Look carefully at what the worshipper did right, and what he did wrong.
He was right that sin is sin. He was right to tell his friend to stop. Nothing in the story says that caring about someone’s sin is wrong. His mistake came at one moment, in one sentence: when he stopped talking about what his friend was doing and started announcing where his friend would end. When he took Allah’s mercy, which belongs to Allah alone, and spoke as if it were his to hand out.
Did you have power over what is in My hand?
In the introduction we said that detachment from control may be the hardest detachment of all. This is control in its most extreme form. Not controlling your money, or your children, or your future. Trying to control someone else’s ending with Allah. Self-righteousness is, at its root, a person reaching for the one thing that was never in human hands.
Remember, too, the monk in “Detach from Perfection,” who told the man who had killed ninety-nine people that there was no repentance for him. The monk and this worshipper made the same mistake from two different directions. One closed the door of mercy on a sinner who was asking for it. The other closed it on a sinner who was not. Both of them were wrong about the door. It was never theirs to close.
Do not claim yourselves pure#
So where does the warm feeling come from? The one from the beginning of this chapter, the feeling of standing a little higher?
It comes from forgetting where the good in us came from.
Allah says:
“He knew you best when He produced you from the earth, and when you were hidden in your mothers’ wombs. So do not claim yourselves pure. He knows best who is truly mindful of Him.”
Quran 53:32
He knew you when you were dust. He knew you when you were hidden in the dark of the womb, before you had done a single good deed. He knows every version of you that has existed since. And He says: do not claim yourselves pure. You are not the one who decides that. He knows best.
And in another verse:
“Have you not seen those who claim themselves to be pure? Rather, Allah purifies whom He wills.”
Quran 4:49
And then a verse that should end the warm feeling for good:
“And if not for the favor of Allah upon you and His mercy, not one of you would have been pure, ever. But Allah purifies whom He wills.”
Quran 24:21
Not one of you. Ever.
Every prayer you prayed was a door He opened. Every coin you gave away, He gave to you first, and then He gave you the heart to let it go. Every detachment in this book that you have managed, even one, was His gift. The light you feel you have is borrowed light.
There is a verse in the Quran that was revealed about believers who were quick to dismiss others. Allah told them not to say to someone who greeted them with peace, you are not a believer, and then He reminded them:
“You yourselves were like that before. Then Allah conferred His favor on you.”
Quran 4:94
You were like that before. Every one of us has a “before.” The person you are looking down on may simply be standing where you stood a few years ago, before Allah did for you what He has not yet done for them. Or what He is about to do.
Now go back to the verse that holds this whole book:
“So that you do not despair over what has escaped you, nor exult over what He has given you. And Allah does not love everyone who is arrogant and boastful.”
Quran 57:23
We have always read this verse about money, and people, and things. But guidance is also something given. Faith is also something given. The ability to let go of the world is also something given. And the verse says: do not exult over what He has given you. Do not turn His gift into your pride.
Look at how the verse ends. Allah does not love everyone who is arrogant and boastful. The verse of detachment ends with a warning about arrogance. As if Allah knew that the person most at risk of arrogance would be the one who had just learned not to be attached to the world.
I am better than him#
The first arrogance in all of creation was spoken in five words. When Allah commanded the angels to bow to Adam, and asked Iblis why he refused, Iblis said:
“I am better than him. You created me from fire, and You created him from clay.”
Quran 7:12
We met these words in “Detach from Perfection,” as the words of someone who would not admit his mistake. Here they show us something else. Iblis had been among the angels when the command came (Quran 2:34). He was not ignorant of Allah, and he was not far from Him. And his fall did not begin with a sin of the body. It began with a comparison. I am better than him.
Every self-righteous thought is a small echo of that sentence. I pray, and he doesn’t. I give, and she doesn’t. I’ve detached, and they haven’t. I am better than them.
The Prophet ﷺ gave us the clearest definition of arrogance that I know:
“No one will enter Paradise who has in his heart an atom’s weight of arrogance.” A man said, “A man loves for his clothes to be good and his sandals to be good.” He said, “Allah is beautiful and loves beauty. Arrogance is rejecting the truth and looking down on people.”
Sahih Muslim 91
Notice first what arrogance is not. It is not good clothes. It is not nice sandals. It is not doing well in life. The man asked exactly the question many of us would ask, and the Prophet ﷺ freed him from it: Allah is beautiful and loves beauty. Arrogance does not live in what you wear or what you own. It lives in the heart.
And then he named its two halves. Rejecting the truth: refusing to accept what is right because it came from the wrong person, or because accepting it would make you smaller. And looking down on people.
These are two attachments. The first is attachment to being right. The second is attachment to being above. And both are attachments to the self, the one we called, at the start of this book, the most stubborn of the four.
The Prophet ﷺ pointed to his own chest three times and said:
“Mindfulness of Allah is here. It is enough evil for a person to look down on his brother.”
Sahih Muslim 2564
Here. In the chest, where no one can see. That is where the real measure of a person is kept. And he said it is enough evil, enough on its own, even with nothing else, simply to look down on someone.
Allah describes the same disease from the outside, in the advice of Luqman to his son:
“And do not turn your cheek away from people in contempt, and do not walk through the earth arrogantly. Indeed, Allah does not love everyone who is self-deluded and boastful.”
Quran 31:18
And in another place, He puts it in a way I find almost gentle in its honesty:
“And do not walk upon the earth arrogantly. You will never tear the earth apart, and you will never reach the mountains in height.”
Quran 17:37
However high you feel, you are still small. The mountains are taller than you. The ground under your feet will outlast you. Standing a little higher than someone else is standing a few inches higher, on an earth you did not make.
And the reward, in the end, is promised to the ones who let this go:
“That home of the Hereafter, We give it to those who do not seek to be high on the earth, nor to spread corruption. And the best ending is for those who are mindful of Allah.”
Quran 28:83
Those who do not seek to be high. Not only those who do not seek to be high over others in wealth or power. Also those who do not seek to be high over others in righteousness.
“The people are ruined”#
There is a kind of self-righteousness that does not point at one person. It points at everyone.
People today have no values. Everyone is attached to their phones. This generation is lost. The whole world has gone mad.
The Prophet ﷺ said:
“When a man says, ‘The people are ruined,’ he is the most ruined of them.”
Sahih Muslim 2623
The narrator was not sure of one vowel in the last word, and the scholars note that it can be read in two ways: he is the most ruined of them, or he is the one who ruined them. Both readings say the same thing to us. The person who stands outside the crowd and declares it lost has not escaped the problem. He has become its worst case. Because in that moment he has forgotten his own heart, and he is despairing of the mercy of Allah on behalf of everyone else.
It is very easy to say this about the world, especially in a book about how attached the world is. I need to say plainly: this book is not a diagnosis of people today. It is an invitation to you, and to me.
The speck and the stump#
There is a sentence that is quoted very often, and I have loved it for a long time. But I want to tell you what I found when I looked into it.
“Blessed is the one whose own faults keep him too busy to look at the faults of others.”
It is usually quoted as a saying of the Prophet ﷺ. But when the scholars of hadith examined its chains, they found them weak. Al-Iraqi said its chain is weak, al-Albani graded the longer version very weak, and al-Dhahabi listed the longer sermon it comes from among fabricated narrations. So, following the rule of this book, I will not put his name on it. But the meaning is true, and it is confirmed by things that are authentic.
The companion Abu Hurairah said, in his own words:
“One of you sees the speck in his brother’s eye, and forgets the tree stump in his own.”
Al-Adab al-Mufrad 592 (the words of Abu Hurairah)
A speck. A stump. The size difference is the point. Our own faults are always bigger to us than they appear, if we are honest, and other people’s faults are always smaller than they appear, because we cannot see the rest of their story.
And Allah asked a question of people who had knowledge and used it only on others:
“Do you command people to righteousness and forget yourselves, while you recite the Book? Will you not then reason?”
Quran 2:44
And forget yourselves. That is the self-righteous person exactly. Not wrong about what is right. Just pointed in the wrong direction.
Now look at what the best people who ever lived did instead. Imam al-Bukhari, in his book of authentic hadith, opened a chapter titled the believer’s fear that his deeds may come to nothing without his realizing it. And at the top of that chapter he recorded what Ibn Abi Mulaykah, one of the generation after the companions, said:
“I met thirty of the companions of the Prophet ﷺ, and every one of them feared hypocrisy for himself. Not one of them claimed that his faith was like the faith of Jibril or Mika’il.”
Sahih al-Bukhari, Book of Faith, chapter heading before hadith 48
In the same place, he recorded the words of al-Hasan al-Basri: only a believer fears hypocrisy, and only a hypocrite feels safe from it.
Thirty companions. People who had prayed behind the Prophet ﷺ, who had fought beside him, who had given everything. And each of them was afraid for himself. They were not busy measuring anyone else’s faith. They were too busy worrying about their own.
Aishah once asked the Prophet ﷺ about the verse that describes “those who give what they give while their hearts are fearful” (Quran 23:60). She asked: are they the ones who drink and steal? He said:
“No, daughter of al-Siddiq. They are the ones who fast, and pray, and give charity, and they are afraid that it will not be accepted from them.”
Jami’ al-Tirmidhi 3175 (graded hasan, good)
That is the opposite of self-righteousness. Not a person who has done nothing and fears. A person who has done everything, and still fears, because they know the deeds are not the guarantee. The ending is with Allah.
This is not detachment from caring#
I need to be careful here, because there is a way to misread this chapter too.
Detaching from self-righteousness does not mean we stop caring about right and wrong. It does not mean we never tell anyone the truth, or that we pretend sin is not sin. The worshipper in the story was not condemned for saying stop. He was condemned for saying Allah will not forgive you.
In the introduction we said that detachment lives in the middle, between obsession and indifference. This is one more place where that middle matters. On one side is the person who looks at everyone else’s faults and appoints himself their judge. On the other side is the person who does not care what happens to anyone, and calls that tolerance. Neither is the middle.
The middle looks like this. You can see a wrong and name it, gently, the way you would want it named to you. You can advise someone, privately, without needing them to know that you are better. You can hate a sin and still pray, sincerely, for the person committing it, because you know that the arm’s length could turn for them, and you know it could turn for you.
And when you see a fault, you can do what the Prophet ﷺ encouraged: cover it.
“No servant covers the faults of another servant in this world, except that Allah will cover his faults on the Day of Resurrection.”
Sahih Muslim 2590
The self-righteous person needs other people’s faults to be seen, because their faults are what make him look higher. The detached heart does not need that. It has let go of the need to be above anyone. So it can cover, and advise, and pray, and leave the ending to the only One who knows it.
Turn the lens around#
Come back to that evening. The family, the friends, the colleagues at lunch. The phone, the car, the prayer that was missed for months. And the warm, calm thought: they are so attached.
Now you know what that thought is. It is not clarity. It is the lens turned the wrong way. It is a grain of sand that fell, without you noticing, onto the wrong side of the hourglass, because a moment spent standing over someone else is a moment spent on the self.
So turn the lens around.
Instead of they are so attached, ask: what am I attached to, right now, in this feeling? And the honest answer is usually: to being the one who sees. To being further along. To being better than him.
Then let it go, the way you would let go of anything else in this book. Not by pretending you see nothing. By remembering what you do not see. Their heart. Their struggle. The secret goodness between them and Allah. And their ending, which may be an arm’s length from Paradise.
And then look down, not at them, but at your own feet. The strap of your sandal is right there. Paradise is that close to you. So is the Fire. That is enough to keep any one of us busy for a lifetime.
So do not claim yourselves pure. He knows best who is truly mindful of Him.